Is mutual information symmetric in X and Y?
Conditions
- Applies to any pair of random variables and for which mutual information is defined.
Reasoning, step by step
- State the symmetry property: .
- Relate it to the Venn diagram: the intersection belongs equally to both circles.
- Conclude that the information shared from to equals the information shared from to .
Example
The narrator explicitly states, 'It's perfectly symmetric. I of X semicolon Y equals I of Y semicolon X. What X tells you about Y is exactly what Y tells you about X.' The screen displays .
Common misconceptions
- Treating mutual information as asymmetric, thinking measures only what reveals about and therefore differs from .
- Confusing mutual information symmetry with KL divergence symmetry; the video does not claim KL divergence is symmetric, only mutual information.
Watch the explanation
Connected concepts
Explore next
Related questions
Conditional entropy H(X|Y) measures the average remaining uncertainty or surprise about a random variable X after another random variable Y has been observed. It is defined as the expected value of the conditional self-information h(x|y) over the joint distribution of X and Y.
Conditions: X and Y are discrete random variables.; The sum is taken over the joint alphabet .
Joint entropy is not equal to because adding the marginal entropies double-counts the mutual information I(X;Y) shared between the variables. The correct relationship is (X;Y).
Conditions: X and Y are random variables that may share information (i.e., they are not necessarily independent).
In the entropy Venn diagram, the left circle represents the entropy and the right circle represents . Their intersection represents the mutual information .
Conditions: Suitable for illustrating information decomposition between two discrete random variables and .
When and are independent, knowing one tells you nothing about the other. Mathematically, the joint distribution factors into the product of the marginals, .
Conditions: Applies to the case where and are independent.; The displayed notation uses probability mass functions , , and .
When conditional entropy H(X|Y) is zero, it means there is no remaining uncertainty or surprise about X once Y is known. This implies that X is a deterministic function of Y, so all information about X is completely contained within Y.
Conditions: X and Y are discrete random variables.
Answers are generated from source material and independently checked. Consult the original video or creator if something is unclear.