Skip to content
← All questions

Why are the state prices ψj\psi_j not probabilities, but the transformed vector qjq_j is?

The state prices ψj\psi_j represent the prices of Arrow-Debreu securities, which are monetary values and do not necessarily sum to 1. The transformed vector qjq_j represents risk-neutral probabilities, obtained by multiplying each state price by the gross risk-free factor (1+i)(1+i). This specific transformation ensures that the entries of qjq_j sum exactly to 1, satisfying the axioms of a probability vector.

Conditions

  • The market is a one-period finite-state model.
  • ψj\psi_j are the solved state prices (Arrow-Debreu security prices).
  • ii is the per-period risk-free interest rate.
  • qjq_j is defined as qj=(1+i)ψjq_j = (1+i)\psi_j.

Reasoning, step by step

  1. Recognize that ψj\psi_j are prices of state-contingent claims, not probabilities.
  2. Calculate the sum of the state prices ψj\psi_j; observe that it does not equal 1.
  3. Multiply each state price ψj\psi_j by the gross risk-free factor (1+i)(1+i) to get qjq_j.
  4. Sum the resulting qjq_j values.
  5. Verify that the sum of qjq_j equals 1, confirming it is a valid probability vector.

Example

In the three-state example, the state prices are ψ1=24/55\psi_1=24/55, ψ2=4/55\psi_2=4/55, and ψ3=2/5\psi_3=2/5, which do not sum to 1. Multiplying each by 1+i=1.101+i=1.10 yields q1=24/50q_1=24/50, q2=4/50q_2=4/50, and q3=22/50q_3=22/50. Adding these gives 24/50+4/50+22/50=50/50=124/50 + 4/50 + 22/50 = 50/50 = 1.

Common misconceptions

  • Confusing state prices with probabilities, assuming that ψj\psi_j must sum to 1.
  • Assuming that risk-neutral probabilities are always numerically equal to state prices; they only coincide when the risk-free interest rate i=0i=0.

Watch the explanation

Connected concepts

Explore next

Related questions

Understand why

↗
Find a method

↗
Find a method

↗
Find a method

↗
Meet the concept

↗

Answers are generated from source material and independently checked. Consult the original video or creator if something is unclear.